1974 was the last year when Columbia Records was the source of the songs (at least on a fully distributed album).   The songs were equally divided between sacred and secular, separated on different sides of the record.  

01 Andre Kostelanetz - Joy to the World
02 Kate Smith - O Holy Night
03 John Davidson - The First Noel
04 Julie Andrews - What Child Is This?
05 Mahalia Jackson - Go Tell It on the Mountain
06 Harry Belafonte - Silent Night
07 Leonard Bernstein & NY Philharmonic - O Come All Ye Faithful
08 Doris Day - I'll Be Home for Christmas
09 Stan Getz - Moonlight in Vermont
10 Percy Faith - Christmas Is
11 Yank Lawson & Bob Haggart - The Christmas Song
12 Tony Bennett - I Love the Winter Weather
13 Enoch Light Orchestra - Snowfall
14 Andy Williams - White Christmas